August 25, 2004

Toledo City Paper

High-class Hathaway

Blissfield landmark offers exquisite dining.     by John E. Clark
Hathaway House
424 W. Adrian St.
Blissfield, Mich.
517-486-2141
Tue-Thu: 5 p.m. - 9 p.m.
Fri-Sat: 11:30 a.m. - 10 p.m.
Sun: 1 p.m. - 8 p.m.

Reservations accepted, Business casual

In 1836, a young David Carpenter left his family home in New York State with only $25 but lots of ambition. Carpenter settled in Toledo and worked as a clerk at a general store. In 1838 he moved to Blissfield and opened his own dry-goods store. Wanting to build the finest home between Toledo and Buffalo, Carpenter built his new home in the Greek-revival style in 1851. After his death in 1891, the house went through many years of change and ownership from family members to non-family members, and was converted into a restaurant after the death of prominent owners George and Prudence Hathaway. The restaurant changed management several times, until Sept. 1, 2003, when Tim and Patricia Coonan took ownership of both the House and Stable, keeping the homey feel that the original owners instilled.
Chef Tim Coonan brings to the Hathaway House, an impressive list of experiences in international dining establishments, including the Michelin two-star Chez Messonier and L’Ermitage, both in Provence, France. After his sojourn in Provence, he returned to the states, graduated at the top of his class from the prestigious Johnson & Wales University, and in 1999 became partner and executive chef at P.F. Chang’s in Chicago. His wife Tricia’s experience is equally impressive. A University of Michigan graduate, she has been dining room manager at the Common Grill in Chelsea, and manager and assistant to the chef and general manager at Spiaggia in Chicago.
All of the Coonans’ experiences and talents, combined with the charm and beauty of the home, create a dining experience worth the trip north. Ours started with an appetizer from the newly created menu. The savory caramelized onion tart with watercress, pistachio and orange sections ($6) was not just a delight to the eye, it was a full spectrum of flavors to the palate. Since summer is the season for cold soup, we indulged in the chilled cucumber-potato soup with cured lox and dill crème fraiche ($5) an unbeatable combination of flavor and texture. The pear and endive salad with blue cheese, walnuts, golden raisins and sherry vinaigrette ($5) and poppy seed chive crepes ($7) were also spectacular.
Selecting an entrée is a pleasant chore due to the fine selection of interesting and different dishes. We decided on the Cape Cod bluefish served with a Michigan cherry brown butter vinaigrette, couscous and wilted arugula ($22) and the roasted quail, pancetta with homegrown sage leaves ($27). Each was made with visual intent, as well as complex flavors and aroma. Many of the dishes include ingredients that are locally grown or come from the chef’s own herb garden on the grounds of the home. Cruising the list of Chef Tim’s fantastic desserts, we shared the fior di latte, a citrus-infused milk custard with fresh berries and berry coulis ($6.50) topped with fresh mint. It was the finale to an evening filled with a fantastic cuisine and gracious service.
For more casual dining, the Stable and Tavern offers homemade pizzas, soups, salads, sandwiches and Tavern dinners starting at $11.95. Beverages at the Tavern include a separate beer menu filled with selections from Michigan and Midwest microbrews as well as a large selection of imported brews.
Watch for our upcoming review.
 

Home
Previous Aritcles

[webtrendscode.htm]